Outperforming the S&P 500 consistently is really tough…so tough that even many professional investors struggle to do it over the long run. While there are a bunch of strategies and charting methods out there that traders try, none of them can guarantee you’ll consistently beat the index. Still, some approaches have shown success in certain market conditions or for shorter periods of time. Here are a few strategies that retail investors have had success with:

Momentum Trading

• What it is: This strategy is about riding the wave—buying stocks that have been doing well recently and selling those that haven’t. The idea is that strong stocks will keep rising, at least for a bit.
• Does it work? Momentum trading has outperformed the market in certain stretches. But it can backfire when the market turns choppy, and sudden reversals are always a risk.
• The catch: It requires frequent trades, which means higher fees and taxes. And it can sting if the market flips on you.

Factor Investing (Smart Beta)

• What it is: Factor investing is about picking stocks based on characteristics like value, size, or momentum. Essentially, you’re betting on certain types of stocks to do better over time.
• Does it work? Factors like value and momentum have historically beaten the market at different times, and there are ETFs that let you invest in these factors.
• The catch: These strategies can go through long stretches of under performance, and knowing when to switch factors is tricky.

Tactical Asset Allocation (TAA)

• What it is: This approach involves shifting your investments between stocks, bonds, and other assets based on short-term market trends.
• Does it work? It can outperform by avoiding downturns or capitalizing on specific market conditions.
• The catch: Timing the market is hard, and even the pros often get it wrong. Plus, the constant shuffling can lead to higher costs and tax bills.

Value Investing

• What it is: The classic Warren Buffett strategy…buying stocks that seem cheap based on their fundamentals and waiting for the market to catch on.
• Does it work? Over long periods, value investing has often beaten the broader market. But recently, growth stocks have been stealing the spotlight.
• The catch: You can under perform for years, waiting for the market to value the stocks correctly.

Market Neutral (Long/Short) Strategies

• What it is: This strategy involves taking long positions on stocks you think will go up and short positions on stocks you think will go down. It’s designed to make money no matter which way the market moves.
• Does it work? Some hedge funds have done well with it, especially during volatile times.
• The catch: You need to be good at picking both winners and losers, which is no small feat. Plus, hedge funds charge high fees, and if the market is booming, this strategy can miss out on big gains.

Trend Following

• What it is: A strategy based on technical analysis that involves jumping on board with market trends. If a stock is trending up, you buy it; if it’s trending down, you sell or short it.
• Does it work? It can work well when markets are moving in clear directions, but it struggles during sideways or choppy markets.
• The catch: You have to time your entries and exits well, and that’s easier said than done.

Options Strategies (Covered Calls)

• What it is: You sell call options on stocks you already own to generate extra income, known as a “covered call” strategy.
• Does it work? It can boost returns in a flat or slowly rising market by giving you extra cash from the option premiums.
• The catch: If the stock price shoots up, your gains are capped because you’ve sold the upside. Plus, options can be complex and risky if you don’t know what you’re doing.

Dividend Growth Investing

• What it is: This strategy is about picking companies that consistently grow their dividends. It’s a more conservative play, focusing on income as well as stock price appreciation.
• Does it work? Dividend stocks can be great when the market is volatile or when interest rates are low, and they can provide steady returns.
• The catch: They can lag behind in booming markets, and if interest rates rise, dividend-paying stocks might lose their appeal.

Why Beating the S&P 500 Is So Hard

• Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH): The theory here is that all available information is already baked into stock prices, so consistently finding mispriced stocks is really tough.
• Costs and Taxes: Active strategies mean more trades, which can eat into your profits due to fees and taxes.
• Emotions: A lot of investors get tripped up by emotions, selling when the market dips and missing out on the recovery.

Bottom Line

While there are some strategies that have outperformed the S&P 500 in certain situations, it’s hard to beat the index over the long haul. These strategies often involve higher risks, more effort, and higher costs. For most investors, sticking with a passive approach—like buying and holding an S&P 500 index fund—is usually the safest and simplest way to get solid, long-term returns without all the stress and uncertainty. Even the pros struggle to beat the market consistently, which says a lot!

Suggested Further Reading:

“The 12% Solution: Earn A 12% Average Annual Return On Your Money, Beating The S&P 500, Mad Money’s Jim Cramer, And 99% Of All Mutual Fund Managers… By Making 2-4 Trades Per Month” – by David Alan Carter
Beat The Street and build long-term wealth in the stock market with this simple ETF rotation strategy that automates decision making, reduces risk and volatility in your portfolio, and lets you sleep soundly at night without worries of market bears or bursting bubbles.

Available on Amazon